Smoker Buying Guide

There are several smokers on the market, and each one has some great features and some downfalls. The six smokers described below range from a very expensive outdoor cooker to a small stovetop smoker. There is a smoker for every price range and experience level. The best way to figure out which smoker best fits your needs is to read plenty of BBQ smoker reviews.

Do you need an electric smoker or a charcoal smoker? An electric smoker uses metal heating elements to heat the wood chips that then smoke the meat. You must have a source of electricity available to use this type of smoker. A charcoal smoker uses charcoal to heat the wood chips. A charcoal smoker is more portable, so it might be a better choice if portability is important to you (i.e. to take it camping).  In both types of smokers, the wood chips are soaked in water before being placed in the smoker.

Based on our comprehensive survey of editorial and user electric smoker reviews, we have rated the following three smokers the best overall.

#1 Best Electric Smoker

Cookshack Smokette Elite Electric Smoker

According to our survey of both professional and user electric smoker reviews, the Cookshack Elite Electric Smoker is the best electric smoker on the market. This wonderful smoker can take those old-fashioned methods of smoking to new heights with its convenience. The manufacturer has added an electronic temperature controller with a meat probe to ensure meat is cooked to just the right temperature. The Cookshack Elite can hold full slabs of ribs and whole briskets with a maximum capacity of 20 to 25 pounds. It has simple digital controls, dishwasher-safe parts, and it can be used with or without wood. This is a user-friendly smoker that even allows you to put some vegetables in with your main dish to make a hassle-free meal.

Cookshack Smokette Elite Full Review

#2 Best Electric Smoker

Smokin Tex Pro 1400

The Smokin Tex Pro was rated the second best electric smoker according to the smoker reviews we surveyed. How about enjoying a yummy meal prepared in your own backyard, on a patio, or in your garage? As long as you have a source of electricity, you can utilize the 35-pounds-per-load capacity and the 700-Watt heating element to smoke your meat. Its stainless steel design is easy to clean and easy to use, and it includes a stainless steel drip pan and wheels that lock. Pit barbecue will be your specialty with the use of this smoker.  Very little to no attention is needed while using the smoker, so pour a drink and relax a while.

Smokin Tex Pro 1400 Full Review

#3 Best Electric Smoker

Bradley Digital 6-Rack Smoker

The Bradley Digital 6-Rack Smoker magically combines several popular features for your convenience.  It was rated the third best electric smoker according to the smoker reviews we surveyed. Its digital technology and functionality make preparing a gourmet meal for a large number of people a breeze. The digital technology is state of the art and user friendly for any adult. Enlist this smoker to slow cook many of your favorite meats and poultry using the six available racks and fan. Unlike the old-fashioned smokers, this one maintains a consistent temperature to thoroughly cook the meal. There are no cold spots in the smoker, which ensures juicy, well cooked meats. You can also count on the 500-watt and the secondary 125-watt cooking element.

Bradley Digital Full Review

If you're looking for a charcoal smoker, we only have one recommendation.

#1 Best Charcoal Smoker

Weber 721001 Smokey Mountain Cooker

The Weber 721001 Smoky Mountain Cooker was rated the best charcoal cooker in the BBQ smoker reviews we surveyed. If you love the taste of a traditional electric smoker, you will love the flavors this smoker will create. This cooker offers 481 inches of total cooking area and heavy-duty cooking grates. There is also a porcelain-enameled water pan and a bottom catch pan for easy clean up. The spring-loaded door latch makes the door easier to operate than other cookers. Just put the food in and tend from time to time. Pit barbecue will be your specialty with the use of this smoker.

Weber 721001 Full Review

If you are looking for a smoker under $200 your options may at first appear limited. Still, there are plenty of good options out there. We have found one smoker to separate itself from the pack in easily being the best value smoker on the market today.

#1 Best Budget Smoker

Meco 5030 Electric Grill and Combination Water Smoker

If you’re looking for the best smoker to buy without spending a lot of money, then the Meco 5030 Electric Grill and Combination Water Smoker is the right choice for you. According to reviewers, this is the best smoker to buy for the money, since it is available for under $200. If you’re afraid of tending to charcoal or a wood smoker, you will love this traditional electric smoker. Just put the food in, set it to one of the two cooking levels, and tend to it from time to time. This smoker takes the work out of cooking. Its stainless steel design is easy to clean and easy to use.  It has 351 inches of total cooking area, a 1500-watt heating element, and heavy-duty cooking grates. The decorative heat-resistant wood side and hood handles make this look like a more expensive smoker.

Meco 5030 Full Review

Falling into a category all by itself, there is only one stovetop smoker we can recommend.

#1 Best Stovetop Smoker

Camerons Stovetop Smoker

The Camerons Stovetop Smoker was rated the best smoker to buy if you are in the market for a cooker that can be used right in the kitchen. You can smoke a variety of meats, fish, and vegetables right on the stovetop. It has a stainless steel cover, and it is dishwasher safe. The unit only weighs seven pounds, so it is easy to store and carry. Enjoy meals prepared in your own kitchen or over a fire pit in the backyard.  If you’re afraid of tending to a charcoal or larger electric smoker, you will love the Stovetop Smoker. The smoker is very affordable and would make a great gift for the first time smoker.

Camerons Stovetop Smoker Full Review

A Final Word On Smoker Reviews

Before making a final decision on a smoker, read plenty of smoker reviews to figure out which one is the best smoker to buy for the money. Do you want a smoker you can use inside? Do you want a small smoker that can prepare just the right amount of meat and is still easy to carry? Are you an expert smoker looking to prepare restaurant quality smoked meat, regardless of the price? Consider all of these points as you read through our reviews, and find the smoker that most closely fits your needs. As you can see, there are plenty of great options to choose from when it comes to electric and charcoal smokers.